Vyvanse Dosage for ADHD: Finding the Safe Top of the Window

by Dr Charles Parker on June 17, 2009 · 29 comments

89580994 089f749e90 m2 Vyvanse Dosage for ADHD: Finding the Safe Top of the Window
ADHD Medications: The Frustration of Ultrarapid Metabolizers

ADHD Medications and Ultrarapid Metabolizers: Titration Matters With Vyvanse.

Cookie cutter medicine in psych treatment is on its way out folks – from SPECT reports to simply adjusting the dosage of ADHD medications in the office, the public knows, as do many of the informed docs, that one size, one label, one basal ganglia platitude, one description of one mood, does not fit all. – And using only one dosing strategy for ADHD medications doesn’t cut it.

Functional complexity is the reason we are missing the treatment boat so often. The brain is not in the picture.

Each person deserves a customized approach that will individualize their care. So much of psych medicine now is throwing psychiatric medication at a superficial diagnosis, or even a cookie cutter SPECT report without understanding the patient. Remember SPECT, while helpful, is not directly representative of cellular physiology – it’s a sophisticated biomarker, and often doesn’t compute with current DSM4 codes, as brain function is ignored the current code book.

Questions Abound For ADHD Medications

This brief ADHD medication question and comment on a recent post deserves more attention due to the prevalence of the questions regarding customizing the upper dosage of Vyvanse [video here at CorePsych]- and the science behind why finding the best dose may not be that easy with some.

Question from Daisy:

The first week on Vyvanse, everything was so clear and seemed so right, it’s hard to explain, but my brain was with me all the time. I wasn’t off daydreaming. I had never felt that good, but then it went away after a week. So, we raised the dose, but that never seemed to work again. I’m on 70 mg, I was on 30 mg that first week, so I assumed when it stopped working it was because I needed to work my way up to the appropriate dose. So, we worked up, I think there was only one or two steps in between, up to 70mg where, I am now. My dr stopped, because he says this is the highest dose, and my symptoms are just as bad as they are off the medication.

This is my 4th medicine change, I was on this first, when we got up to 70 mg, with no noticeable improvement, he took me off of this and tried, that barrel shaped one, that can’t be crushed, I can’t remember the name off-hand. That didn’t make me feel any better, then we tried Adderal XR and again no change. At this point he said those were my only options and to give up at this point, so I asked to go back on Vyvanse, and I tell him it works OK, so he doesn’t take me off of it and leave me with nothing, as he was going to do before and I thought I could play with the dosing on my own, to see if I can get it to work again. I want that week back, that week of feeling clear headed and coherent. Of knowing what was going on around me and understanding people when they talk to me.

The Problem of Ultrarapid Metabolism - My Answer

Without a few more details this sounds at first like you were right: a good example of too much too fast – too rapid a titration, not leaving about 1-2 weeks near the top dose before increasing to the next, and, as you point out, no appropriate slow steps in between. With adults I rarely go faster than 10 mg increase every 1-2 weeks, watching carefully for that expected 2 hr increase in DOE in the PM with that carefully adjusted dose – and I fully admit I am very conservative. The only problem with that process in my office is the patient’s becoming impatient, as I rarely create a drug excess with that protocol.

Many docs feel the same way yours does, as they stay only with the package insert. He is simply following the ‘insert rules’ as Vyvanse is a controlled product, and just as I have almost no experience writing for antibiotics – and simply won’t write for them – he is simply doing a good job following guidelines.

My possible contribution to this conundrum is a mix of common sense and experience over the time that Vyvanse has been out – with a dose of clear science about the CYP 450 genetic polymorphisms of 2D6 [see the many posts here - just type 2D6 into SEARCH].

1. Common sense: Adults already often go over 30 mg Adderall XR [roughly = 70 mg Vyvanse] regularly – and can be titrated based upon watching carefully for the DOE as outlined in this post. If your medical person goes very slowly they will not have a problem, and I don’t recommend that you ‘play with the dose’ – even tho your doc may not be working with you at this moment – do stay tuned with your medical team with your actions, or you very likely will loose [justifiably so] their medical support.

2. Experience: I do go up past 70 mg in dose at times, and have heard whilst in CA last week that some have not only gone up to 400mg, but have recommended simply ‘going to the top’ without careful titration, a practice I completely dismiss as dangerous. I always steer completely away from an answer to the question of ‘just what is your top dose?’ because that discussion drives practitioners away from the essential practice of careful titration into cookie cutter medicine – a point with which I am completely philosophically at odds… don’t get me started!

3. The genetics: about 1.5% of folks are 2D6 [the AMP pathway] ultrarapid metabolizers [UMs] as reported in many books such as Drug Interactions in Clinical Practice leaving practitioners with a challenging few that just can’t correct their ADHD on average doses, as they burn up the effectiveness just too fast. These individuals are often unhappy and disappointed, often with long unsuccessful trials of meds. For these folks only someone completely comfortable with those higher [notice I didn't say 'highest'] doses of medications [using the predictable, careful titration strategies outlined in multiple posts here at CorePsychBlog and at http://www.squidoo.com/vyvanse is recommended.

Best bet: talk these issues over with your doc, and see if he is comfortable with a little increase - if not perhaps they can suggest someone more experienced in your community to walk carefully down that path with you. Do shoot for the 12 hr duration [DOE] as noted frequently in these blog posts. [Video on Vyvanse and DOE}

Interesting and common problem - just talked to some of the docs in CA last week about this very issue - thanks for sharing it with our readers.

A brief recording to pull it together [6.08 min]:

cp

 Vyvanse Dosage for ADHD: Finding the Safe Top of the Window

Digitally available now at Nook, Kindle, Barnes and Noble.
ADHD Medication Rules – PDF For Your Desktop  
ADHD Medication Rules | Paying Attention To The Meds For Paying Attention – Kindle Version

h grey Vyvanse Dosage for ADHD: Finding the Safe Top of the Window

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Cheryl, Wellbutrin can block the pathway for Dex, only moderate, but if the person is s slow burner that moderate blockage of 2D6 could spell the difference. With the other symptoms is sounds much like you have an associated metabolic imbalance that would require further investigation in careful interview and history. cp

Not a problem from anything in my experience or reading. cp

I have a problem with the comment under point number 1- "or you very likely will loose [justifiably so] their medical support". From what Daisy shared, she doesn't HAVE medical support! Her doctor sounds like he thinks treating ADHD is optional. Would he treat other medical conditions the same way? The fact that she FEARS he may withdraw helping her with any meds tells me this doc is way over his head and shouldn't be dabbling in this treatment. He is NOT justified in withdrawing his "support". He should be asking himself why she feels it is necessary to take her treatment into her own hands in the first place- and then refer her to someone who is more exprienced in this area.

Cheryl, Interesting problem indeed - seen every day in our offices. The societal problem of disdain for stimulants is so pervasive that the implication often arises that those with ADHD are closet addicts, and, following that line of non-science, anyone trying to help them get stimulants is acting as a perpetrator of evil, drug addiction and against the code of "do no harm." Pretty crazy, but undeniably pervasive. Parallel to that view is the simple problem of dis-ease with the meds period. Many have no clue about stimulant meds, fear societal or med board reprisals, and just want to keep their jobs. I do agree with your doc in the sense that oftentimes if I don't even know a little what to do with a med that's not on my formulary. I also frequently don't have specific referrals in mind in their specific locality. It's a bind that does loop back to the patient to keep looking. cp

On this Cheryl, and completely agree. I keep thinking we should have a certification course for ADHD med management, but don't expect it in this lifetime... cp

Colin, I think, it's late now, I answered this on another posting... bottom line, hang tough, get to the pharmacy the tide is turning! cp

Star, Right on the same track... the therapeutic window is alive and well in every med check with every practitioner in our offices. Look for 12 hr DOE no matter the dose, and watch the details at the end of the day cognitively to see when your dose burns out. cp

AN UPDATE & A FEW QUESTIONS (5 to be precise; although some include sub-questions. I counted them after writing this!) 1st question: is there a need to wean off of any of the stimulant meds before switching to a new one? Obviously I know that with the new, you start low and slow again. Does how slow depend on the stimulant? Other questions are interspersed below... (After writing all this, I just counted them -- there are 4 more questions, basically one per section). Update: Per drs orders, I am now taking adderall w/o the vyvanse to be able to see more clearly its effects. Although initially I was opposed to this, I can definitely say that it is easier to see the differences! I had thought that the vyvanse plus 20 IR wasn't making much of a difference (at least the morning dose), so when I took the 30 mg IR by itself I was expecting that it would be about right. Nope! It was way too much. I had not been tired before, and shortly after I was completely tired and unable to do anything at all! It was awful. I then slept and worked on not dwelling on my negative thoughts for the next 6 hours. After that, I felt normal for me again. Then I took 10 mg because I did not want to repeat! It also occurred to me that day that the adderall plus the vyvanse previously had likely been too much. Even though I didn't think I'd noticed any changes, upon reflecting, I had been irritable all week. External events, that normally, although probably distracting would not be aggravating, were. Onset for adderall has been about 25-30 minutes. It's been 20 mg and I've felt good, but also able to concentrate, be less restless, and not have so many thoughts swirling in my mind. DOE has pretty much been exactly 4 hrs as far as I can tell, which I believe is within typical range? (I know you cite 6, but every where else I see 4 - why is that?) Another question: that first night after taking the 10 mg (which did not have much benefit) leading into about the 5th hour, I was pretty tired. By the 6th hour I was fine. Why is that? Similarly on another day, the 20 mg second dose of the day, I felt tired for that first hour or so (which again is the 5th hour of the first dose and the onset of the second one). I'm confident that the aspect of up/down is part of these shorter acting stimulants, but what I don't understand is why I feel tired when it's coming off and then fine afterwards, even if I don't take any more medicine (like in the evening). Then again, this regimen is pretty new. On a side note, we would not be sticking with the IR as a general rule...it's what I have currently filled and is serving as a sort of test before deciding to switch to XR I guess. Isn't there one other amphetemine formulation besides Adderall and Vyvanse? I can't recall off the top of my head. Suppose I wind up taking 20 mg adderall IR 3 times a day (or 4 at the most depending on when I started it) and it works well....what would be the normal switch if going to adderall XR? Because 20 mg adderall 3x is 60 and 4 is 80, but I didn't think XR came in those doses. Is that how it works or no? I do have your book on adhd meds, thank goodness - that's how I knew that the first 30 of adderall was too much and subsequently figured out the other problem too. But it doesn't answer these questions, most of which seem to me to be pretty straightforward! So my 5 questions (extracted from the paragraphs) are: 1) Is there a need to wean off of any of the stimulant meds before switching to a new one? Does how slow when starting a new one depend on the stimulant? 2) Typical DOE range for Adderall IR is 4-5 hrs? I know you cite 6, but every where else I see 4 - why is that? 3) Why was I tired roughly the 5th hour into the dose when I had not been previously? The 6th hour I was good. 4) Isn't there one other amphetemine formulation besides Adderall and Vyvanse? 5) What's the switch from Adderall IR to Adderall XR if someone is taking 20 mg IR 3 or 4 times daily? Every now and then I want to completely give all this med stuff up because it's frustrating and takes a while, but right when I'm about to do that, I see a glimpse of how things can be and so I just try again. Thanks for your assistance asap. This website and the information is invaluable!

jm, 1. No 2. Adderall IR = 4-6 hr, dialed in carefully max is 6 for some. 3. Please, for your own sake, put the magnifying glass down on the table. Microscopic analysis can make you goo-goo. Look for patterns over time. Answer: Getting used to the med. 4. 80 IR = ~ 20 XR two times a day... no other long lasting formulation. 5. See 4. Each person is different, you and your doc will figure it out. You have now graduated to the 'informed consumer' crowd ;-). cp

Thanks. I appreciated and smiled at your advice for #3 - I am very analytical with everything, and many times too much so; but sometimes it's hard to know when I'm doing it too much and when it's just being careful or precise. If it's all I can think about, then I know it's too much and I just do my best to change those thoughts! I haven't gotten to the xr yet, but the last few days on the adderall have been really good. Almost every objective has improved dramatically (the others I just haven't had the opportunity to observe yet due to circumstances). Overall I'm even sleeping better. Which, I don't know if that makes sense, but I'm definitely doing and feeling better rested in the mornings. It can be difficult to remember to take it each time, 4 times a day, but that's the advantage of the xr...I just hope that if/when we go to that, I would have a similar response. Is the onset for adderall xr still about 25-30 minutes? It's been consistently good for this amount of time and that is just so new for me that I almost don't want to believe it or get my hopes up. I'm waiting for it to just not have these benefits. I also haven't had any side effects that I'm aware of. Sometimes I think it's just that I slept better or wonder if it's the placebo effect..but at the same time, I've tried before and not succeeded. Now I'm trying, and I am succeeding for the most part. I still have to work on the stuff though, of course! I wouldn't want that differently. I'm almost want to know what would happen if I didn't take it for a day or two or three to see what would happen -- if my willpower and recent successes would keep me going and have the same effect. It's funny (odd, funny) that despite all this and despite everything I've read (which is a lot) about adhd, medications, therapy/coaching, et cetera I still have my doubts about the diagnosis for myself - not because I don't want it though. I guess that doesn't really matter, as long as I do what I can to function better. It's nice to be able to function better. I have to go....or I'll be late! I just wanted to finish this real quick (gotta work on that!) Thanks again for sharing your expertise! Have a great day, jm

jm, Your diagnostic issues are not unlike thousand of other folks wondering about the current codes describing ADHD appearances unrelated to careful thinking about real brain function. I think you read my book on Medication Rules wherein I work hard to answer compelling diagnostic and treatment issues often overlooked. cp

Dr. Parker, I'm a 28 yr old female who'd thought about an evaluation for ADHD etc. for several years but never had actually followed through on it until a few months ago - mostly because I've always managed and been successful. But some relatives and others close to me told me to go to a psychiatrist. It took them 3-4 weeks of convincing me I should go before I even considered making an appointment. I did not go with the idea of being evaluated specifically for adhd though, said as little as I could about it, and answered the questions on as low of a scale as possible yet still being honest. I'm somewhat knowledgeable in the area and had debated this many times. I own a copy of your e-book on adhd medication and have read it several times; I've also read/watched almost all of the information posted on your site. I have some questions regarding the top of the window and effectiveness in general. I started with 30 mg Vyvanse, noticed a difference with project avoidance but not other differences. It took about an hour to an hour and a half to set in, from what I could tell. Increased dose weekly by 10 mg; all with no other changes. No side effects either during this time. I went to 70 mg and was physically and mentally less impulsive/hyperactive (most notably when I was really making an effort to do only one thing that was quiet & not involving the computer - thus able to focus better) with still less project avoidance. That lasted for at least 3-4 days, maybe as much as a full week and then went away. Time of onset stayed the same - roughly an hour to an hour and a half. DOE from time of taking it was 10 hours, sometimes 11. Objectives I was looking for to change but still did not notice even with the 70 were: remembering what/how to say things, remembering where I put things, being able to stop doing something when I need to and have already reminded myself several times, being able to listen in conversations more easily, being less confused with overload of information or choosing what to do first (even when I already have a list broken into steps). If any of these are not specific enough objectives or reasonable to expect changes with medication, please tell me. There are other issues too, but I don't know how to state them clearly. I'm wondering about the top of the window because I had read in one of your comments to someone else that the long onset could indicate that they were on too much. Is that only true if onset changes as you increase? I'm also wondering again about the top of the window (or basically just getting it right) because now what I am taking is: 70 mg vyvanse and 20 mg adderall ir together in the morning, and another 20 mg adderall in the afternoon. This is very new to me; I didn't notice any drop off with the adderall and I'm not sure about the onset. I'm supposed to take it in the afternoon, but haven't yet because I'd gotten sick and was trying to rest up that afternoon. The next day I was trying to sleep all day and drink water so I didn't take either...but normally, I would stick to what the dr says. I have yet to be on this regimen (70 mg vyvanse + 20 mg adderall 2x) for any length of time, but should I expect to see those other changes with my objectives? Should I just do exactly this regimen for a week or so to see and then maybe change? I was thinking to do 10 mg adderall 2x instead of 20 at first, or 20 mg in am with vyvanse and only 10 in afternoon...I just don't want to be on too much. With taking the adderall, would I maybe need less of the vyvanse? I keep thinking of all these possibilities and I' m not sure what I should actually do. I'm making careful notes about when I take these medicines, other medicines I'm taking (i.e. antibiotic for being sick), breakfast, and notice of symptoms as best I can. I was glad to not have to switch from vyvanse all together, because it was helping in at least one regard and I had no negative side effects. I just want to be sure about not doing too much and basically knowing when I've found what's right. Two other quick questions -- how long for onset with adderall ir typically? And, can I use that typical time or should I add to it since I was longer with vyvanse? I know DOE for adderall ranges from 4-6 hours. As far as the necessity of a protein breakfast: I do make sure I get it and I've been taking the medicine right along with it or shortly after I've started eating, but I was wondering how much protein is enough? Some of the things I've done include: 1-2 C. reg. oatmeal with 1/4 to 1/2 C peanut butter mixed in and a little honey (I'll usually eat half and save the rest for the next day), a cereal w/ @ least 2-3 g protein per serving plus either spoonful of peanut butter or handful of nuts both with milk, one day I didn't have anything so I just ate a half piece of chicken breast. I'm thinking about maybe waking up earlier than I need to, having an easy protein thing - like a shake, taking the adderall, and going back to bed for a bit. Then when I actually get up, get ready, eat something (either w/ or w/o much protein), and take the vyvanse on my way to work or right before I leave. The mornings have always been so hard for me (at least since adolescence)- even when I get enough sleep I rarely feel rested. When I do feel rested, it can still be hard! I have always been one of those people who really needs sleep (childhood and on) and a lot of it. If I'm healthy (no cold/other illness), exercising, and eating...9 hours is what I aim for, although 8 is just fine. 7 or less I can manage for a few days at a time, but then I really struggle with everything a lot more. Anything less than 6, I'm miserable later in the day or I get sick. Anyways, I got sidetracked. If you can let me know about the objectives, the vyvanse and adderall, and how much protein is enough I would really appreciate it. Thanks so much!!

Jm, Thanks for your interesting review, your deepening appreciation of the How-Stims-Work, and these questions. Honestly I could do a much better job talking to you in person, because I am quite certain you are missing something - I just don't have a clue what it is. 1. Late onset is atypical at low doses unless the dose is too low. That late onset with increased doses is the tip off to too much. 2. I just don't see a need to augment with Adderall if the diagnosis, the comorbid conditions and the underlying metabolic issues are straight. 3. No definitive answer on the protein, we simply see folks doing better with AM dose of 10-20 Gm. 4. Adderall, like the Vyvanse, should onset in 30-45 min. Do consider these possibilities: 1. You are one of those 5-7% of Caucasians or 3% of the African Americans who simply can't take AMP products [genetic polymorphism of 2D6]. 2. You have an additional metabolic problem quietly grinding away at your liver metabolic rate: IBS, Constipation, Substance abuse etc? 3. You could simply be a very fast burner, and after these latter considerations simply need to go up to the the 12 hr DOE on Vyvanse. cp

Thanks for your help. I suppose it's possible that there's another metabolic issue, but what would that mean in terms of finding a solution with the meds? As far as I know there's no history of IBS etc in my family, and although yes, sometimes I do have digestive difficulties -- but never any problem that was a big deal or consistent day to day. I have no known allergies. The adderall was supposed to help in the morning; from what I've read the Vyvanse typically takes an hour or so to be effective (although for me it was a bit longer even at the lowest dose). You mentioned that late onset with increased doses indicated too much, is that just in general? My onset has never changed and I've noticed no difference with the adderall. I guess I will just keep trying....part of me wants to stay with this class of meds because I've had no side effects at all, but at the same time, the benefit has just been a little. One other quick question, even if there is a comorbid condition - let's say dysthemia - wouldn't the adhd still need the treatment? I'm just throwing that out there, but there's no diagnosis and I don't struggle very much with the thoughts/feelings aspect due to therapy. What about my treatment objectives? Thanks!

jm, You bet, cormobidity needs its own game plan separate and distinct from ADHD. Treatment objectives will be difficult to assess when you aren't in the Window, either out the top or below the bottom. You just can't assess the accuracy when the target is so completely missed. cp

Thanks again for your quick reply! That makes sense about the accuracy. Did you answer my question about what it means as far as the meds even if there is some other underlying metabolic problem? (I don't REALLY think there is though). By target you mean the window right? What I was wondering about more was the reasonableness of the objectives I listed--are those things that can be improved with this type of medication and is it reasonable to look for it as doses increase or medications change? Absolutely for the comorbidity (if it's even there) - but since the adhd seems to be more prevalent and more of a struggle, I guess that's the reason for starting there. Thanks again. jm

jm, Yes, this CorePsych Blog post does a decent job of breaking down liver, gut and metabolism. Yes, the target it the window, objectively defined by specific office questions regarding brain function. cp

Dr. Parker, Have you had patients become diabetic after using vyvanse? Do Adhd medications increase blood glucose levels? I am confused...do I stop vyvanse? My Dr. called and scheduled a glucose tolerance test due to labs indicating high numbers. Never had this problem until after using vyvanse. Any thought are appreciated. Thanks, ry

Robin, Diabetes is not downstream from Vyvanse, but does indicate comorbid metabolic challenges that, if not corrected, can make the ADHD refractory to treatment. cp

It doesn't sound as though Robin has been diagnosed with diabetes, but rather that her/his doctor noticed an atypically high sugar level after routine blood work. Robin states clearly that he/she didn't have this issue previously. Talking about comorbidity completely ignores the facts that Robin presented. I started taking Vyvanse about a year and a half ago. Before Vyvanse, I'd never had a single blood test come back with a blood glucose level that was remotely out of the norm. I recently had two blood tests (one at my annual physical; another several weeks before when I visited my MD after a spate of headaches), and both revealed glucose levels that, while still normal, were noticeably higher than my usual levels; enough so that my PCP--who's also an endocrinologist--commented on it. Does that mean Vyvanse is the culprit? Of course not. But it's certainly possible and worth consideration. In fact, Duke U is launching a study to examine this very issue. No one can definitively state at this point whether Vyvanse has an adverse effect on blood sugar. It's only been on the market for a few years now. Oftentimes, additional side effects don't manifest until the initial patient population has been on a drug for a significant period of time. So no person can make a statement that "diabetes is not downstream from Vyvanse."

Tom, Interesting reply, and not on my radar at the moment - thanks for weighing in! One additional point on your same vein is worthy of consideration: I have seen significant dietary changes with stimulants in general, in the unanticipated hyperglycemic direction. Often we see some decreased appetite, but sometimes it does swing the other way... and with neurotransmitter testing [as with a person just seen in the office yesterday] her neurotransmitter PEA was off the chart to start with, only aggravated by the stimulant to become more dysregulated with sugar cravings. - Have also seen this phenomenon with SSRIs. Thanks for your feedback, good points for consideration. cp

Dr. Parker, My 15 yr old son has been on Vyvanse for a few months at his request due to the longer duration. He seems to be less moody and his grades have improved but some days are just better than others. On the "good" days he's more motivated, gets things done more effectively and is just plain happier. On the "off" days he still gets work done but he doesn't take much initiative and he doesn't have the joy that he does on the "good" days. He is pleased with Vyvanse as compared with the Adderall. He does try to eat a protein breakfast but he skipped breakfast this morning yet it was still a "good" day. Thanks for your insights. Susan

Susan, Thanks for the comment, I have to redo the video here, had some problems with the previous, but this needs to be explicated more specifically, So many other ideas that could help: Good multivitamin, Zinc supplement, Omega 3 FA bout 2-3 Gm, all shotgun, but might trim him up just a bit. If the next tweak doesn't do it, check out the details for investigation on the Neuroscience page, Best, cp

Why don’t MDs combine stimulant types? I have tried Concerta, Ritalin IR, and Vyvanse. Each type (methyl. v. amph) affected me very differently! Both positively, both helped with major ADD symptoms, but completely different ones: methyl. with internal processing and obsessiveness; Vyvanse with doing tasks, maintaining focus, and getting my brain ‘up to speed’ for quick activities like driving. Neither on its own really ‘cuts it.’ I don’t think it’s a dose-level issue, as my doc is willing to go notably above FDA regs, with careful consideration and monitoring. My MD believes my ADD underlies other comorbid concerns, but won’t consider combining stimulants. I trust her, but I don’t really understand why! Why don’t MDs combine the two? (I wish they would! ) Thank you, B-Philadelphia

Brian, Be careful with mixing, I do recommend against it for the following reasons: 1. Not commonly appreciated, but seen in the lit and from comments on the road [never have done it myself because of my reading]: AMP products are 2D6 substrates, and MPH products [not 'methyl,' another subject all together] block 2D6, creating the possibility of a challenging drug-drug interaction. 2. In the lit they both have similar actions qualitatively, blocking the reuptake of DA and NE, but also qualitatively differ in effect. Statistically speaking, the absolute best effect size with stimulant meds is Vyvanse, by far. 3. I suspect the differences may occur with you, as often they do with others: breakfast, food on taking the meds, DOE [titration imprecision], sleep, even foods eaten - especially with the immediate release/mechanical release products. [Vyvanse, the only prodrug {with no immediate release features}, shows only slight variations with food, but can occur with some.] 4. Speculation: Neurotransmitter imbalances, a step deeper in the stream of med adjustments, may be encouraged by either set of drugs because they do have different methods of action. She's completely correct - you just need a bit more attention to the details. Be well, cp

I think Dr. Parker is one of the most rational doctors I've known save my own, and one would be well to heed his advice. I too have gone through the gambit of ADD medications, save Desoxyn, which though is on occasion the right medication for an individuals brain is far too disorienting for most. The barrel shaped pill Daisy was Concerta, the most ineffective, if least risky towards abuse by far, of the stimulant medications (in my experience.) I spent five years on Adderall XR, from 30 up to 90mg over that time period, and for me, it was the perfect (if one can call any medication with the side effects stimulants can cause perfect) fit for my brain chemistry. My doctor was always willing to listen to me, and never afraid of throwing the PDR out the window if reality spoke louder than paper, so increasing my dosage within reason was fine by him. Then I turned 25, lost my father's insurance, and could no longer afford Adderall XR, and instead switched over to Vyvanse which offers a 12 month free 30 pill fill PAP card. I started off at 60mg with Vyvanse, and I am 100% with you on how it changed my life. I was normal for about 1 week (after three days of feeling little to nothing), and had never felt such peace. It faded as quickly as it came though. Being a prodrug, it functions a bit more like an anti-depressant than the typical stimulant medication - it has to build up a bit in your system, and then should ideally stay at a constant level at all times. Like those happy pills, which make the clouds part for a while, eventually the normality resumes and one finds themselves no longer finding the treatment obvious. I went up to 70mg for a week. Nil once more. Because Vyvanse is so new, the ceiling dose of 70mg preempted the logic of making a single capsule of greater strength (I have no doubt this will change over time, as most of the doctors I know of take it to 100mg before settling into worry over protocol). I, however, was now in a position of having to get one RX for free, and pay for one as well anyway, as I required more than 30 pills monthly. I went to 100mg, then 120, albeit with greater periods in between... finally I was on 140mg, and, again, 2 70mgs a day was the most I could take unless I wanted to pay 350+ out of pocket for the one medication (and I am on a number of them). Always fascinated by psycho pharmacology, I did a lot of reading and thinking, and came up with a solution: I asked to be put on 70mg of Vyvanse once each morning, and another 60mg of immediate release generic Adderall to be taken 20mg at a time from noon until 60pm as I needed it. The Adderall was $22 for 90 20s, the Vyvanse free, and while the latter kept me at a steady level of normal at all times, the former gave me the remaining relief and yet without the peaks and valleys typical of 4 hour dosages - much reduced by the constant 70mg "steady" underneath. I will no doubt need up to 75-90mg of Adderall eventually, but any good doctor who has no reason to fear abuse (because dependence with amphetamine is inevitable, but completely different in nature from addiction) should know the brain is different for all, and the stimulant is always fast on the growth of tolerance, and the combo means having to do what is best for the patient, putting out of mind the decrees set by the FDA (which most likely makes such decisions never having been on or been close to someone on any of the medications they decide about for you.) Most key in what the good doctor said Daisy (I won't approach CYP 450, though it is relatively new to me and voraciously fascinating in most all ways, effecting (pardon my hazy stab here) 60-70% of what goes through your pathways to the perhaps 10-15% the next most influencing CYPs (shrug) will.) Read his lips and mine, do not press the desire for an addictive medication without documentation and a fair understanding of the science behind why it needs to be pressed. Doctors other than the rare Dr. Parker and my own, come in about 3 flavors: Overly flippant, overly cautious, and addiction "specialist." Your doctor, may simply be too cautious, but that he removed you from medication completely (malpractice in my opinion), I fear he may be #3. These are the doctors who will deny severe panic prone patients Klonopin, and when the seizure hits get an injunction to hold you for 72 hours figuring heroin was the cause of the grand-mal. Get a new doctor. Sadist or not, if you do not feel you are being respected in your concerns, he/she is the wrong one to be going to anyway. You have to build trust for both your sake as well as the Psychiatrist, because if he feels he can trust you, he won't fear you're trying to get high when you need a 3 day fill of .5 Xanax because your friend died, but trust you need the respite, while you will get that respite without having to seek alternate means. Last thing: It's been shown many a time that an addictive medication given under the care of a doctor greatly lowers the chance a patient will self medicate and truly ruin their lives. Get help if you feel you need it, because if you know there is something wrong, there is something wrong - no MD can make it go away because of incompetence. Best of luck Daisy, and Dr. Parker, thank you for helping instead of hurting. You are one of the true good doctors, I feel your heart in it.

Gordon, Thanks for the kind remarks - it does appear that you are following DOE guidelines, and doing the very best that can be done with the entire universe of money, ADHD, medication durations and drug interactions. No prob with Adderall and Vyvanse, as you likely know, AMP with AMP is no problem... AMP with MPH is a problem, as MPH does moderately block that 2D6 pipeline. About the other docs - having spoken to hundreds of them I can affirm that only a very few are flippant, some very reasonable folks are overly cautious [simply based upon insufficient clinical experience], and some addiction folk are simply anti-biology on any level. On the other hand you have docs like Patrick Carnes PhD, an international addiction specialist [yes, not an MD], who is very biologically oriented and very well informed about brain function. My overall impression and the reason for these postings: the medical dialog about these ADHD/stimulant matters is in sad disrepair - and apparently worsening with the attitude fostered by some that discussing these medications with pharma reps is out of the question - some of the most esteemed medical training facilities refuse to speak to pharma while pharma pays most of their research. The obvious dichotomy: let's look at the numbers and not participate in the dialogue about patients - we'll loose our objectivity! Sounds like you have a very thoughtful doc who is working well with you, - and, who knows, some docs may come around just thinking carefully about this dialogue [and the science] and the Daisy folks out there. Thanks, cp

Trackbacks

  1. [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Dr Charles Parker, Mungo. Mungo said: RT @drcharlesparker: #Vyvanse Dosage for ADHD: Finding the Safe Top of the Window http://t.co/UszkyE4 via @AddThis [...]

  2. [...] My Reply Do look very carefully at your duration, your DOE as discussed in this post on Vyvanse dosing, and assess if it has crept up to the 14 hr range. While not always the accurate barometer [having [...]

Previous post:

Next post: